Be ready

Repair orders win lemon claims. Here's how to get good ones.

Every trip to the service drive creates a record. That record is what attorneys, arbitrators and manufacturers look at first, so make sure it tells your story.

Last reviewed · General information, not legal advice

Every visitGet a repair order, even if nothing was fixed
Your wordsThe complaint line should match what you said
DatesIn and out, so days out of service add up

What to check on every repair order

  • The complaint line. It should describe the problem the way you described it: "Vehicle stalls at stoplights, check-engine light on," not "customer states concern." Ask for a correction before you leave.
  • Date in and date out. These are how days out of service get counted. If the vehicle sat waiting for parts, that time should show.
  • Mileage in and out. This drives the offset-for-use formula.
  • What was done. Parts replaced, software updates, technical service bulletins applied, or "no problem found."
  • A copy for you. Always leave with a copy, even for warranty work where you paid nothing.

"Could not duplicate" still counts

Intermittent problems are the hardest to fix and the easiest to dismiss. A repair order that says "could not duplicate" or "operates as designed" still proves you reported the defect on that date and gave the dealer the chance to fix it. Keep them all. Video of the problem happening, with the date visible, makes these visits much stronger.

Your lemon file checklist

  • Every repair order and invoice, in date order
  • Purchase or lease contract, and the window sticker or FTC Buyers Guide
  • Warranty booklet and any service contract
  • Photos and video of the problem
  • Emails, letters, texts and chat transcripts with the dealer or manufacturer, plus any case numbers
  • Your written defect notice and proof of delivery
  • Towing, rental, rideshare and travel receipts
  • Recall notices and records of recall repairs

Other tips

  • If it's unsafe, don't drive it. Have it towed to an authorized dealer and keep the receipt.
  • Use authorized dealers for warranty repairs so the manufacturer can't say it wasn't given the chance.
  • Don't sign a "goodwill" settlement or release from the manufacturer without legal advice.

Sources: Chapter 681, Florida Statutes · How the Florida Lemon Law works (FL AG)

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Does a 'could not duplicate' visit count as a repair attempt?

It documents that you reported the defect and gave the dealer an opportunity to repair it, which is why attorneys want every one of them. How a specific visit is treated depends on the facts.

What should the repair order say?

The complaint should describe the problem in your own words, with accurate dates and mileage in and out, and list what the dealer did.

Done going back to the shop? Start here.

Start your free review