Two kinds of arbitration
Manufacturer programs. Some manufacturers run a dispute-settlement program that has been certified by the State. If yours does, you generally have to use it first. If the program doesn't decide within 40 days, or you disagree with its decision, you can move on to the state board.
The Florida New Motor Vehicle Arbitration Board. This state board is administered through the Attorney General's Lemon Law program. You request it with the Attorney General's Request for Arbitration form, and the program screens the request for eligibility before a hearing is set.
Deadlines
A request to the Board must be filed no later than 60 days after the Lemon Law rights period expires, or within 30 days after the final action of a certified manufacturer program, whichever is later. Because the rights period is 24 months from delivery, most people's deadline is about 26 months after they took delivery. Our deadline calculator will do the math.
The hearing
- The Board hears the dispute within 40 days after the request is approved and decides within 60 days.
- Bring every repair order, your purchase or lease contract, the defect notice and proof it was delivered, and receipts for towing, rentals and other costs.
- Expect the manufacturer to present its side too. Bring the vehicle if you're asked to, and be ready to explain exactly when and how the problem happens.
- Attorney's fees are generally not recoverable in the Board proceeding itself. Many consumers still have an attorney prepare the case, often on terms arranged with the attorney in advance.
After the decision
If the Board rules for the consumer, the manufacturer must comply within 40 days. Either side can appeal an adverse decision to circuit court within 30 days of receiving it. Appeals follow their own rules on fees, so get advice before deciding.
RVs use a different program
Motor home disputes go to a state-qualified RV mediation and arbitration program instead of the Board. See our RV lemon law guide.
Real Board decisions
2020 Jaguar F-Pace. The infotainment system, which also ran the backup camera, was intermittently inoperable. The Board awarded a refund.
2022 Tesla Model Y. The owner reported roughly 100–150 miles of range against an advertised 330. The Board awarded a replacement vehicle.
2019 Nissan Pathfinder. The backup camera intermittently failed to work. The Board awarded a replacement vehicle.
Summaries of public decisions from the Florida Attorney General's case summaries. Not results obtained by LemonLink or any participating attorney. Every case turns on its own facts.
Sources: Chapter 681, Florida Statutes · How the Florida Lemon Law works (FL AG) · FL AG: Hearings before the Arbitration Board · The Florida Bar: Florida's Motor Vehicle Lemon Law
Tampa Bay